Understanding and Distinguishing Various Audit Criteria for Certified Quality Auditor Success

If you’re preparing for the Certified Quality Auditor (CQA) exam, understanding different audit criteria is absolutely essential. Whether it’s external standards, contracts, specifications, policies, or internal quality management system (QMS) requirements, these criteria form the backbone of an auditor’s evaluation process. Getting familiar with various CQA exam preparation materials that simulate ASQ-style practice questions can give you a significant edge.

In fact, using a comprehensive CQA question bank ensures you’re exposed to real exam topics and the diversity of audit criteria you’ll face both in the exam and in your auditing career. This kind of preparation helps cement your understanding so you’re confident identifying and applying the correct audit criteria during audits in industries worldwide.

For a deeper dive, you can also explore our main training platform offering full quality and auditing preparation courses and bundles — perfect companions to the question bank. And the bonus? Free lifetime access to a private Telegram channel with bilingual explanations in Arabic and English supports continuous learning post-purchase.

What Are Audit Criteria?

Audit criteria represent the standards, policies, or requirements against which an auditor judges a process or system during an audit. These criteria act as the benchmark to assess conformance and identify gaps or nonconformities. Understanding the scope and source of these criteria allows a Certified Quality Auditor to perform thorough, accurate audits, either internally or externally.

Generally, audit criteria fall into several key categories. Each serves a distinct role but often overlap, depending on the audit context:

External Standards

External audit criteria come from standards recognized outside the audited organization. They can be:

Industry standards such as automotive IATF 16949 or aerospace AS9100.
National standards like ISO standards adopted by country-specific bodies (e.g., ANSI in the USA).
International standards issued by bodies like ISO or IEC, widely adopted globally.

These standards provide universal, accepted benchmarks for quality, safety, environmental management, and more. Audits conducted against these criteria verify compliance and identify improvement areas. For example, ISO 9001 is a frequent audit criterion for quality management systems.

Contracts and Quality Agreements

Contracts between customers and suppliers often define explicit requirements that audits must verify. Quality agreements, a type of contract, establish clear quality expectations, responsibilities, and acceptance criteria for product or service delivery.

These contractual criteria go beyond standards by being legally binding and project-specific. Auditors must examine whether contractual clauses, such as delivery timelines, product specifications, or regulatory compliance, are met.

Specifications

Specifications set specific technical or performance criteria for products, processes, or materials. They can originate internally or externally and typically include detailed numeric limits, tolerances, or procedural steps.

Auditors check actual outputs and processes against these specifications to ensure consistency, safety, and quality. For instance, a manufacturing line may have specifications for part dimensions or acceptable defect rates.

Policies

Policies document an organization’s principles and methods on how quality and related activities are managed. While policies are overarching and often flexible, they provide guiding criteria auditors use to understand organizational intent and align audits accordingly.

Examples include a company’s environmental policy or health and safety policy, which define broad goals and commitments, driving detailed procedures and standards underneath.

Internal Quality Management System (QMS)

The internal QMS is an organization’s documented system used to manage quality consistently. It includes procedures, work instructions, forms, process maps, and records designed to meet the above criteria.

Auditors use the QMS documents as audit criteria during internal audits and sometimes in supplier assessments. The QMS verifies whether the organization’s processes align internally and externally with specified standards and customer expectations.

How Do These Audit Criteria Differ?

While all audit criteria serve as reference points, their differences are important:

Source: External standards come from recognized bodies outside the organization, contracts are legal agreements with customers or suppliers, and internal QMS criteria originate within the company.
Purpose: Standards aim for general compliance and best practices; contracts enforce specific commercial obligations; specifications control technical product parameters; policies set organizational direction; QMS ensures systematic quality management.
Binding nature: Contracts are legally enforceable, whereas standards and policies guide but don’t carry legal weight unless made mandatory by law or contract.
Detail level: Specifications are very detailed and technical, while policies are broad and principles-based. QMS documents vary from high-level manuals to detailed work instructions.

For auditors, distinguishing these is fundamental for selecting appropriate audit evidence, applying correct criteria, and making accurate judgments. This distinction also frequently appears in CQA exam topics and real-world audits alike.

Real-life example from quality auditing practice

Imagine you’re a Certified Quality Auditor assigned to perform a supplier audit for a manufacturing company. Your audit scope includes checking compliance with ISO 9001, reviewing the supplier’s internal QMS, and verifying conformance to contractually agreed product specifications.

During your audit, you first review the supplier’s quality manual and procedures (internal QMS) and check if they align with clauses of ISO 9001 (external international standard). Next, you examine the contract quality agreement, specifically the agreed tolerance limits on materials supplied, and check actual batch records for evidence of compliance.

Finally, you verify the product itself against the technical drawings and specifications documented in the contract. This comprehensive approach ensures that all audit criteria — external standards, contracts, specifications, and internal documents — are accounted for, leading to an informed audit conclusion and objective nonconformity findings if any.

Try 3 practice questions on this topic

Question 1: Which of the following is an example of an external audit criterion?

A) An organization’s quality manual
B) Customer quality agreement
C) ISO 9001 standard
D) Internal work instructions

Correct answer: C

Explanation: ISO 9001 is an internationally recognized external standard used as an audit criterion to assess quality management systems. The others are internal or contractual documents.

Question 2: What is the primary purpose of a quality agreement in auditing?

A) To describe legal and quality requirements between parties
B) To list internal procedures of the supplier
C) To set general organizational policies
D) To define product technical specifications only

Correct answer: A

Explanation: Quality agreements are contractual documents that define the roles, responsibilities, and quality requirements legally binding both customer and supplier.

Question 3: Which audit criterion is usually the most detailed and technically specific?

A) External standards
B) Policies
C) Specifications
D) Internal QMS documents

Correct answer: C

Explanation: Specifications provide detailed technical or performance criteria that products or processes must meet, making them highly detailed and specific compared to other criteria.

Wrapping Up: Why Knowing Audit Criteria Matters for You

Grasping the differences and applications of diverse audit criteria is a cornerstone skill for every Certified Quality Auditor. The ability to identify and apply the correct criteria ensures effective audit planning, performance, reporting, and follow-up. It’s a topic that consistently features in CQA exam preparation and plays a pivotal role in real-world audits.

For a solid edge in both your exam and professional audits, consider leveraging the full CQA preparation Questions Bank. It contains numerous ASQ-style practice questions with detailed bilingual explanations tailored to the latest ASQ Body of Knowledge. Also, explore our main training platform for full quality and auditing preparation courses and bundles.

Remember, the purchase of the Udemy question bank or the full audit courses grants you FREE lifetime access to our exclusive private Telegram channel — a unique support resource with daily posts providing deeper insights, practical audit examples, and extra related questions all in Arabic and English. Access details are private and shared only with our enrolled students, ensuring you receive personalized coaching every step of the way.

Put yourself on the fastest path to becoming a highly proficient Certified Quality Auditor by mastering audit criteria now!

Ready to turn what you read into real exam results? If you are preparing for any ASQ certification, you can practice with my dedicated exam-style question banks on Udemy. Each bank includes 1,000 MCQs mapped to the official ASQ Body of Knowledge, plus a private Telegram channel with daily bilingual (Arabic & English) explanations to coach you step by step.

Click on your certification below to open its question bank on Udemy: